Shelter Island Hotels

Welcome to Shelter Island, the hidden gem of New York's Long Island region. Whether you're looking for a romantic getaway or a family-friendly vacation, Shelter Island has it all. And when it comes to accommodation options, hotels should be at the top of your list. In this blog post, we will explore the many reasons why choosing hotels is the best choice when travelling to Shelter Island.

First and foremost, hotels offer unparalleled comfort and convenience. After a long day of exploring the island's stunning beaches or hiking its picturesque trails, coming back to a cozy hotel room is a true luxury. With comfortable beds, room service, and amenities like swimming pools or spas, hotels provide the perfect escape from the bustling city life.

Moreover, hotels in Shelter Island are strategically located, making it easier for you to explore all the attractions this beautiful island has to offer. Whether you're interested in visiting the iconic Shelter Island Historical Society or discovering the island's vibrant culinary scene, having a hotel as your basecamp will save you valuable time and transportation costs. Plus, many hotels offer complimentary shuttle services or are within walking distance of popular attractions.

If you're travelling with your family, hotels in Shelter Island are known for their family-friendly facilities and services. From spacious rooms to children's play areas, hotels understand the unique needs of families and go above and beyond to create a comfortable and enjoyable experience for everyone. Some hotels even provide special amenities such as cribs or babysitting services, ensuring that both parents and children can relax and make the most of their vacation.

Last but not least, choosing a hotel in Shelter Island allows you to enjoy the island's natural beauty at your own pace. Many hotels boast stunning waterfront views or are nestled amidst lush landscapes, providing the perfect backdrop for a peaceful and rejuvenating stay. Wake up to the sound of waves crashing against the shore, sip your morning coffee on your private balcony, and let the tranquil atmosphere of Shelter Island wash away all your worries.

In conclusion, when it comes to accommodation options in Shelter Island, hotels are the perfect choice for a comfortable, convenient, and memorable stay. With their prime locations, family-friendly facilities, and stunning surroundings, hotels offer a sanctuary for travellers seeking a true island getaway. So, pack your bags and get ready to immerse yourself in the beauty of Shelter Island โ€“ and let the hotels take care of the rest.

Popular in Shelter Island

Table of contents

The Pridwin Hotel Sunset Beach Seven - A Boutique B&B On Shelter Island

View all photos

The Pridwin Hotel

📍 81 Shore Road

Greenport Antique Carousel is placed a 10-minute drive away, and Crescent Beach is around 10 minutes on foot from the 4-star Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island.

Check Availability
Add to compare

Cheap Hotels

View all photos

Sunset Beach

📍 35 Shore Road

Fireboat Firefighter Museum is placed a 10-minute ride away, and the locally run aquaculture Southold Bay Oysters Farm is a 10-minute drive from the 4-star Sunset Beach Hotel Shelter Island.

Check Availability
Add to compare

Pet Friendly Hotels

View all photos

Seven - A Boutique B&B On Shelter Island

📍 7 Stearns Point Road

Mashomack Preserve is placed 3.8 km away, and East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation is around a 10-minute drive from the 4-star Seven - A Boutique B&B On Shelter Island.

Check Availability
Add to compare

Hotels in Shelter Island

Airport nearby ๐Ÿ›ฌ Republic, Hartford-Brainard, Tweed-New Haven, Long Island MacArthur
Rating ๐Ÿ… 41
Shelter Island Hotels ๐Ÿ›Ž๏ธ 5
Cities Nearby ๐ŸŒ‡ Shelter Island Heights, East Marion, Bay Point
Minimum Price ๐Ÿ’ธ 399$
Hotel with a view ๐Ÿ” The Pridwin Hotel
Most comfortable Hotel ๐Ÿ›๏ธ Sunset Beach
Hotel with balcony ๐ŸŒค๏ธ Seven - A Boutique B&B On Shelter Island
Shelter Island Hotels FAQ
Which Hotels have a lot of guest reviews?
Here are some Hotels that have the highest number of reviews:

Location